It’s something we all use but rarely discuss; toilet paper. The wrong one can be unkind to sensitive skin, and for most, there’s a glaring difference between the cheap toilet paper you’re forced to use when out in public and the softer, more comfortable toilet paper used at home.
But if you have a septic system, you have an additional thing to consider; compatibility with your septic system. Some toilet paper can clog up the works and become a real pain in the rear. The following six toilet papers, however, are all completely safe for septic systems.
We’ve tested all of these toilet papers to see how they feel and how they compare so that you don’t have to. Hopefully, the following reviews will help you pick out the bathroom tissue that’s the perfect fit for your backside and your budget.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites
|Best Overall||Quilted Northern H&PC-74326||
|Best Value||Amazon Brand Presto!||
|Premium Choice||Charmin Ultra Soft||
|Cottonelle Ultra CleanCare||
The 6 Best Toilet Paper for Septic Systems – Reviews 2021
1. Quilted Northern H&PC-74326 Ultra Plush Toilet Paper – Best Overall
Most people would agree that two-ply toilet paper is more comfortable than single-ply, but how about three-ply? That’s what the Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper offers. You get three plys of cushiony soft tissue to keep your backside clean. The quilted pattern helps with both comfort and cleanliness, and since it’s ultra-absorbent, you don’t need as much as you do with other brands.
These rolls feature 319 sheets each, much larger than a standard roll of toilet paper, even if some competitors did have larger rolls. Still, for the amount of toilet paper on each roll, they’re priced pretty affordably. We also like that they don’t seem to shed much at all, which was a major issue with some of the other brands we tested.
2. Amazon Brand Presto! – Best Value
Presto! is Amazon’s in-house brand of toilet paper. They’re priced considerably cheaper than the competition, but that doesn’t mean its quality is lower. In fact, we were so impressed with this toilet paper at this price that we think it’s the best toilet paper for septic systems for the money.
Naturally, this paper is completely safe for use in any standard septic system. The rolls are mega-sized, so each one is approximately equal to four regular-sized rolls. It’s not the softest of all the toilet paper we tried, but it’s still quite plush and never leaves you raw. However, it seems to leave behind less lint than other brands, which you can really notice when you use it to blow your nose.
For those concerned about the environment, this product is produced sustainably, limiting your impact on the climate. The pulp used to create this paper comes from responsibly managed forests, which leaves a smaller footprint.
3. Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch Toilet Paper– Premium Choice
Cheap toilet paper can feel more like sandpaper than tissue, which is why we gravitate towards ultra-soft, plush toilet paper like the Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch Toilet Paper. Not only is it one of the softest tissue papers we’ve seen, but it’s also approved by ROTO-Rooter as completely safe for septic systems, so you never have to worry about it clogging things up.
One advantage of this toilet paper is the gigantic mega rolls that are five times the size of a standard roll of toilet paper. You get 24 rolls in a pack, which equates to 123 standard-sized rolls. Each roll contains 338 sheets total, so you’re getting more than 8,000 sheets of toilet paper in a package. Luckily, Charmin is more absorbent than a lot of the competition, so it tends to last longer since you don’t need as much each time.
Our only real complaint about the Charmin Ultra Soft is the price. It’s quite a bit more expensive than other toilet paper that we tried. But to be fair, you are getting a lot on each roll and this paper is kind to your backside. Can you put a price on comfort?
4. Cottonelle Ultra CleanCare Strong Toilet Paper
If you have problems with toilet paper that’s too thin and falls apart when you use it, then you might consider switching to the Cottonelle Ultra CleanCare Strong Toilet Paper. It’s stronger and thicker than most brands, though it’s still 100% septic-safe, sewer-safe, and clog-safe. And since this toilet paper is sourced sustainably from forests that are responsibly managed, you don’t have to be concerned with your impact on the environment.
This toilet paper is single-ply, but that ply is thick enough to be extremely absorbent. Each roll has 388 sheets, so the 24 rolls in a pack are the equivalent of 128 regular-sized rolls.
Though it’s stronger than many brands we compared it against, the Cottonelle Ultra CleanCare isn’t nearly as soft. It also tends to shed a lot more than some of our favorites, even though it is strong enough not to break apart while wiping.
5. Scott Rapid-Dissolving Toilet Paper
Made specifically for RVs, boats, busses, and any other type of tiny enclosed waste system, the Scott Rapid-Dissolving Toilet Paper is designed to breakdown much faster than other types of bathroom tissue so that it never clogs up the system. In fact, it breaks down four times faster than standard toilet paper, so you can be certain it’s safe for your septic system.
We love how quickly this paper dissolves, but we weren’t as happy with the price. This product is several times more expensive than other options. Worse, the rolls are much smaller than competitors, so you’re getting even less on each roll. Luckily, this toilet paper is made from responsibly sourced materials, but that’s not helping to make it any more affordable.
6. Georgia-Pacific 19841 Envision Toilet Paper
Does your family go through toilet paper as quickly as a department store? If so, then you might consider the Georgia-Pacific 19841 Envision Toilet Paper. This is bulk toilet paper, so it comes in large rolls and massive quantities. Each roll contains 550 sheets and you get 40 rolls in a single package. But they’re all single-ply, and it’s not the strongest toilet paper we’ve seen.
Naturally, single-ply toilet paper is pretty thin. This one is also a bit rough and doesn’t feel as nice on your skin. Moreover, it’s plain. There’s no design on it, which means it’s not quite as effective at keeping you clean.
If you have sensitive skin, you might want to spend a little more and opt for something a bit softer. Still, this toilet paper is completely safe for septic systems and it can save you some money if you’re ok with the downsides.
Toilet paper is something that most people purchase without giving much thought to it. It’s something you use but don’t often consider unless it’s unavailable for some reason! So, how do you decide which toilet paper to trust on your backside? For us, the decision boils down to a few key factors that we’re going to share with you in this short buyer’s guide.
When you have a septic system, the most important thing to ensure with any toilet paper is that it’s certified as septic safe. If it’s not, then it could potentially clog your septic system. This will cause the effluence to back up into your home, creating a terrible smell that will fill your house. And it’s going to take some professional help to unclog.
Standard rolls used to contain 100 sheets of toilet paper. But today, there’s not much consistency between brands. You’ll also see terms like supreme roll, mega roll, giant roll, and more, but there’s no standard set for these sizes. Instead, you’ll have to see how many sheets are included on each roll. Some contain as many as 388 sheets per roll, which will obviously last much longer than a roll with just 100 sheets.
Another difference between toilet papers is how many plys of paper are used. Single-ply toilet paper is just a single thin sheet of paper while double-ply has two thin sheets. There’s even triple-ply toilet paper available. More layers can mean better absorbency, a plusher feel, and stronger paper that’s less likely to break apart while you wipe.
You might not think too much about the absorbency of your toilet paper, but between two types of toilet paper, you can use less of the more absorbent brand and get the same results. This can save you money in the long run since you’re essentially getting more out of each roll.
For many, this is the most obvious trait to compare between toilet papers. How does it feel when you wipe? Is it rough like sandpaper or does it feel nice and soft? If you have to wipe a lot, rougher toilet paper can be very uncomfortable.
You might have noticed that different toilet papers have different patterns. Some use ridges, others use designs. But that pattern is for more than just decoration. After all, who cares what your butt wipe looks like? What it’s actually for is to help clean you off better. That texture helps to grab onto things easier, leaving you with less left behind after you wipe.
Have you ever blown your nose and been left with a bunch of white fibers on your face? That’s called shedding, and most toilet paper does it to some degree. But it’s not just shedding when you sneeze, it’s shedding on your backside as well. A little shedding isn’t going to cause any damage, but it can be annoying, so if it bothers you, look for a brand that doesn’t shed.
At the end of the day, all of these products do the same thing; they let you clean your butt. It’s not glamorous, but it’s got to be done. Truth is, they all do this job effectively, so you have to determine what price you’re willing to put on things like comfort, absorbency, and strength. If those things don’t matter to you, then there’s always bulk toilet paper available for lower prices that’s just less luxurious than the competition, but completely usable nonetheless.
Toilet paper is something you might not give much thought to until it’s no longer available. Once you realize how much we truly rely on this simple invention, you might never look at wiping the same again. But you don’t need to personally feel each of these papers to know how they stack up. We already tested them for you, so hopefully, our reviews will serve as a sufficient replacement.
Ultimately, we’re going to trust Quilted Northern Ultra Plush. It’s completely safe for septic systems so yours won’t get clogged, which is helped by the fact that you don’t need as much of this toilet paper since it’s ultra-absorbent. Best of all, it’s extremely soft when you wipe and doesn’t leave behind any little white fibers like other brands we tried.
When price is a major factor, we’re more likely to choose the Amazon Brand Presto! toilet paper instead. Though it’s made from sustainably sourced pulp, this paper still manages to offer an incredible value at a very affordable price.
Looking for some luxury in the lavatory? You might try the super-absorbent Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch that’s even ROTO-Rooter approved as safe for septic systems.
Featured Image Credit: New Africa, Shutterstock
Pete has been working in the trades since high school, where he first developed a passion for woodworking. Over the years, he has developed a keen interest in a wide variety of DIY projects around the home. Fascinated by all sort of tools, Pete loves reading and writing about all the latest gadgets and accessories that hit the market. His other interests include astronomy, hiking, and fishing.
As the founder of House Grail, David’s primary goal is to help consumers make educated decisions about DIY projects at home, in the garage, and in the garden.
- 1 A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites
- 2 The 6 Best Toilet Paper for Septic Systems – Reviews 2021
- 2.1 1. Quilted Northern H&PC-74326 Ultra Plush Toilet Paper – Best Overall
- 2.2 2. Amazon Brand Presto! – Best Value
- 2.3 3. Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch Toilet Paper– Premium Choice
- 2.4 4. Cottonelle Ultra CleanCare Strong Toilet Paper
- 2.5 5. Scott Rapid-Dissolving Toilet Paper
- 2.6 6. Georgia-Pacific 19841 Envision Toilet Paper
- 3 Buyer’s Guide
- 4 Conclusion