House Grail is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

9 Best Renters Insurance in Massachusetts In 2023 – Reviews & Top Picks

young couple standing and hugging together looking happy in front of their new house

young couple standing and hugging together looking happy in front of their new house

If you live in the Bay State, you know how important it is to have the right renters insurance. With so many options out there, it can be hard to figure out which one works best for your needs.

That’s why we put together a list of the 9 best renters insurance in Massachusetts in 2023. Here, you’ll find reviews of our top picks. So, whether you’re looking for coverage that covers the basics or something more comprehensive, we’ve got you covered!

Read on to find the policy that works best for you and your budget. Good luck, and happy hunting!

house divider

A Glance at Our Winners in 2023

Rating Image Product Details
Best Overall
Lemonade Insurance Lemonade Insurance
  • Fast claims processing with AI
  • Giveback program for charities
  • Excellent customer service
  • Best Value
    Second place
    National General Insurance National General Insurance
  • Flexible policy options
  • Competitive pricing
  • Strong network of agents and brokers
  • Third place
    Nationwide Nationwide
  • Wide range of coverage options
  • Customizable policies
  • Discounts for safety features and multi-policy holders
  • Plymouth Rock Assurance Plymouth Rock Assurance
  • User-friendly website and mobile app
  • Discounts for safety features and multi-policy holders
  • Additional add-on coverages available
  • Esurance Esurance
  • Affordable premiums
  • Customizable coverage
  • Bundling discounts
  • The 9 Best Renters Insurance in Massachusetts

    1. Lemonade Insurance – Best Overall

    lemonade insurance logo

    Lemonade Insurance is a great option for renters in Massachusetts who are looking for a modern, tech-forward insurance experience. The company’s renters insurance policies are competitively priced and provide comprehensive coverage for a range of events, including theft, fire, and water damage.

    One of the standout features of Lemonade’s renters insurance is its ease of use. The company’s website and mobile app are both intuitive and user-friendly, and policyholders can quickly file claims and manage their policies online.

    In addition, Lemonade uses Artificial Intelligence (AI) and machine learning to help expedite the claims process, making it faster and more efficient than many traditional insurance companies.

    Another appealing aspect of Lemonade’s renters insurance is its emphasis on social good. The company’s Giveback program allows policyholders to choose a charity or nonprofit organization to receive a portion of their unclaimed premiums. This feature can help renters feel good about their insurance purchase and support causes they care about.

    Overall, Lemonade Insurance is a top choice for renters in Massachusetts who are looking for affordable, comprehensive coverage and a modern, user-friendly insurance experience.

    • Fast claims processing with AI
    • Giveback program for charities
    • Excellent customer service
    • Limited coverage options
    • Not available everywhere
    • No in-person agents

    2. National General Insurance – Best Value

    National General Insurance Logo

    If you’re a renter in Massachusetts, National General Insurance is an ideal choice for comprehensive coverage at an attractive cost. Their renters insurance policies cover a wide range of scenarios from theft and fire to water damage, as well as liability protection should any accidents or injuries happen on the leased premises.

    National General Insurance stands out for its exceptional policy choices, so renters can design their coverage to fit their particular requirements.

    Moreover, the firm has a vast network of independent agents and brokers distributed all over Massachusetts, which makes it simpler than ever to locate an insurance policy that suits them best.

    When it comes to renters in Massachusetts, National General Insurance is undoubtedly among the best picks. Not only does this reliable insurer provide extensive coverage and customized customer service, but it also offers unparalleled affordability and flexibility for those seeking a sense of security as well as protection for their belongings.

    • Flexible policy options
    • Competitive pricing
    • Strong network of agents and brokers
    • Mixed customer reviews on the claims process
    • Limited online account management options

    3. Nationwide

    nationwide insurance logo

    For Massachusetts renters, Nationwide is the perfect choice due to its extensive coverage options and exceptional customer service. Its renters insurance policies provide protection against fire, theft, and water damage, as well as liability expenses that may be incurred on the property.

    Moreover, tailored packages are available so customers can select a plan which best meets their needs in terms of deductible amounts and coverage limits.

    Not only is Nationwide’s coverage extensive, but they also provide a wealth of discounts for renters living in Massachusetts. You could be eligible to receive money off your policy if you have smoke detectors or security systems installed in the rental unit or even if you possess multiple insurance policies.

    Another strength of Nationwide’s renters insurance in Massachusetts is the company’s strong network of agents and brokers. With thousands of agents and brokers across the country, renters in Massachusetts can easily find a local agent who can provide personalized support and advice throughout the policy lifecycle.

    If you are looking for comprehensive coverage and unbeatable customer service in Massachusetts, Nationwide is definitely worth a look. With superb discounts and an extensive network of agents and brokers, you can’t go wrong with Nationwide’s renters insurance.

    • Wide range of coverage options
    • Customizable policies
    • Discounts for safety features and multi-policy holders
    • Strong network of agents and brokers
    • May be more expensive than some other insurers
    • Discounts and promotions may be limited

    4. Plymouth Rock Assurance

    Plymouth Rock Assurance Insurance Logo

    Established in 1982, Plymouth Rock Assurance is a regional insurance company based out of Boston that provides renters insurance and other forms of coverage to individuals living in the northeastern United States.

    A major benefit of their service lies within its customizable nature; customers have the ability to adjust their policies according to their personal needs and preferences, selecting from variable coverage amounts and deductible options. As such, each policy can be tailored for optimal protection at an affordable cost!

    You’ll have extra peace of mind with Plymouth Rock’s additional insurance coverage options, including identity theft protection and electronics coverage. Furthermore, the company has a team of devoted agents and customer service representatives to answer your questions at any time during policy renewal cycles.

    For even easier access to manage policies or file claims anytime you please, take advantage of their user-friendly website or mobile app!

    Renters in Massachusetts who are searching for customizable coverage, personalized service, and discounts should certainly consider Plymouth Rock.

    • User-friendly website and mobile app
    • Discounts for safety features and multi-policy holders
    • Additional add-on coverages available
    • Limited availability in some areas outside of the northeastern United States
    • May not be the most technologically advanced insurer
    • Limited coverage options compared to some other insurance companies

    5. Esurance

    Esurance Insurance Logo

    For anyone looking for reliable renters insurance in Massachusetts, Esurance is an ideal choice. Not only do they offer budget-friendly premiums and discounts when you bundle with auto insurance, but also offer customizable coverage options to tailor it to your wants and needs.

    Furthermore, their user-friendly website and mobile app make managing policies or filing claims simpler than ever before!

    Choose tailored coverage for your needs and budget with Esurance’s customizable renters insurance policies. The company’s plans provide protection for personal property, liability, and additional living expenses in the event of a covered loss.

    Plus, you have access to superior customer service 24/7 on all our platforms—phone, email, or online chat! So make sure to check out Esurance today and give yourself peace of mind that your rental is protected.

    Taking all factors into consideration, Esurance stands out as a great choice for renters insurance in Massachusetts due to its competitive prices, a myriad of customizable coverage options, and user-friendly online tools.

    • Affordable premiums
    • Customizable coverage
    • Bundling discounts
    • Convenient digital tools
    • Limited coverage options
    • Not available in all states

    6. Allstate

    Allstate Insurance Logo

    Allstate is an excellent choice for renters in Massachusetts looking for comprehensive coverage, affordable pricing, and exceptional customer service.

    Renters in Massachusetts face unique challenges due to the state’s extreme weather conditions, and Allstate’s policies cover losses due to natural disasters such as wind, hail, and snow damage.

    Allstate’s policies also include liability protection and coverage for additional living expenses, which can be particularly important in the densely populated areas of Massachusetts, where it may be difficult to find alternate accommodations in the event of a covered loss.

    One of the areas where Allstate really shines is customer service. You can access their 24-hour customer service hotline anytime you have a question or need help. They also have an online chat feature that makes it easy to get answers quickly and conveniently.

    If you’re looking for reliable coverage with plenty of helpful customer service options, Allstate is an excellent choice for renters insurance in Massachusetts.

    With a strong financial standing and a reputation for excellent customer service, Allstate is a reliable and trustworthy option to consider signing up for. You’re sure to get quality coverage for your personal belongings and liability protection.

    • Comprehensive coverage options
    • Affordable pricing
    • Excellent customer service
    • Limited discounts

    7. Amica Insurance

    Amica Insurance Logo

    Amica Insurance offers competitive renters insurance policies for Massachusetts residents looking to protect their belongings and personal property. The company has been in operation since 1907, giving customers peace of mind that they’re working with an experienced provider.

    Their plans offer a variety of coverage options and discounts, making it easy to find a policy that fits your needs and budget. And as with other leading providers, Amica has 24/7 customer support, so you can always get help if you have a question or need assistance.

    With Amica, it’s easy to find the right renters insurance policy for your needs. As a renter in Massachusetts, you’ll be able to enjoy comprehensive coverage at a competitive price.

    It made the list thanks to its reliable coverage, variety of discounts, and excellent customer service. So, if you’re looking for a rental insurance policy with an experienced provider, Amica could be the right choice for you.

    At the end of the day, Amica offers renters insurance policies that provide protection for personal property, legal responsibility, and loss of use. These are all things that mean something special to renters.

    Furthermore, there are alternatives available such as identity theft coverage and valuable item coverage! Additionally, Amica offers a wide range of discounts like multi-policy discounting along with claim-free or loyalty discounts—all to help you save more money!

    Amica is a smart option for renters in Massachusetts, offering an easy-to-use website and mobile app to manage policies, as well as 24/7 customer service support. Not only does Amica provide reliable coverage at a competitive price point—their excellent customer service sets them apart from other insurers.

    • Valuable items coverage available
    • User-friendly website and mobile app
    • Multiple discounts available
    • Potentially higher premiums
    • Limited coverage for high-risk items

    8. Farmers Insurance

    Farmers Insurance is a leading insurance company in the United States, providing a wide range of insurance products, including home, auto, life, and business insurance. The company was founded in 1928 and has since grown to become one of the largest insurers in the country, serving more than 10 million households across all 50 states.

    Their policies cover a wide range of risks, including theft, fire, and water damage, and they offer additional coverage for valuables such as jewelry and electronics. With their online platform and mobile app, it’s easy to manage your policy and file a claim.

    Farmers Insurance is known for its personalized customer service and comprehensive coverage options. They offer a variety of discounts for policyholders, including multi-policy discounts and safe driving discounts.

    In addition, the company has a strong commitment to sustainability and social responsibility, with programs that support local communities and the environment.

    While the company is generally well-regarded, it’s important to note that there have been some customer complaints about claims handling and customer service. It’s always a good idea to do your own research and read reviews before choosing an insurance provider.

    • Reliable coverage
    • Comprehensive policies
    • User-friendly platform
    • Potentially higher rates
    • Coverage limitations

    9. Horace Mann

    Horace Mann Insurance Logo

    If you’re looking for reliable renters insurance in Massachusetts, Horace Mann is a safe bet. With comprehensive coverage for personal property and liability protection as well as additional living expenses due to covered incidents like theft, fire, or water damage, the company strives to ensure that all their clients feel safe from unexpected losses.

    Horace Mann offers identity theft protection and equipment breakdown coverage—benefits that are not typically found with other insurance providers. Even better, their user-friendly online platform allows customers to conveniently manage their policies and submit claims in a snap!

    Despite Horace Mann’s higher premiums and limited discounts, the company offers extensive coverage paired with a user-friendly platform, making them one of Massachusetts’ best for renters insurance.

    • Comprehensive coverage
    • Identity theft protection
    • Equipment breakdown coverage
    • User-friendly online platform
    • Higher premiums
    • Limited discounts

    divider 4

    Buyer’s Guide: Choosing the Best Renters Insurance in Massachusetts

    What to Look for in Renters Insurance

    In this section, we’ll take a look at the parameters used to rate these companies and policies. When it comes to renters insurance, you want to make sure that your coverage is comprehensive so that all of your belongings are protected in the event of an accident or theft.

    Policy Coverage

    When looking at renters insurance policies, you should always make sure that the policy provides coverage for your belongings, liability protection in case of an accident or injury on your property, and personal property coverage for any furniture or other items.

    Think about what kind of coverage you’ll need—if you own expensive items like jewelry, electronics, or antiques, consider getting additional coverage for those specific items.

    Your policy can often be customized to include additional coverage to accommodate your needs. Speak to your insurer or browse their website to learn more so that you can make an educated decision about which is right for you.

    Close-up Of A Person's Hand Filling Renters Insurance Policy Form
    Image Credit: Andrey_Popov, Shutterstock

    Customer Service & Reputation

    Customer service is key when it comes to selecting an insurance provider. You want to be sure that you can get in touch with your insurer quickly and easily if you need to make a claim or ask any questions about your policy.

    Take the time to do some research into customer reviews and ratings for each of the companies, as this will give you an indication of the quality of their customer service.

    You never know when you’ll need help with your policy, so it’s important to make sure you choose a company that values customer service and satisfaction.

    Claim Repayment

    In the event of an accident or theft, you want to be sure that your claim will be processed efficiently and fairly. Your insurer should have a clear process in place for filing claims, and they should be willing to answer any questions you may have about their process.

    The best companies will work with you to ensure that your claim is settled as quickly and efficiently as possible so that you can get back on track as soon as possible.

    Claim form for fill out
    Image Credit: danielfela, Shutterstock

    Price of Policy

    When evaluating different renters insurance policies, consider the cost of the policy itself in relation to the coverage it provides.

    Look for policies that offer competitive pricing, as well as discounts, if you combine two or more policies with the same company. Many companies also offer flexible payment options to help make their policy more accessible and affordable.

    Plan Customization

    Finally, look for renters insurance policies that allow you to customize your plan according to your specific needs.

    Make sure that the company you choose allows for customization so that you can design a policy that fits your budget and provides adequate coverage for your belongings.

    The best companies will also provide guidance and advice to help you make decisions about what type of coverage is right for you.

    divider 5


    What is renters insurance?

    Renters insurance is an affordable way to protect your belongings and yourself from the unexpected. It covers losses from theft, fire, vandalism, and other disasters that could damage or destroy the items you keep in your home—there’s also liability coverage for any accidents that occur at your residence.

    It can even provide additional coverage for medical expenses if someone is injured while at your home. With renters insurance, you can rest assured that you and your possessions are protected.

    How much does renters insurance cost in Massachusetts?

    Renters insurance premiums vary depending on the coverage you choose, the value of your belongings, and where you live. In Massachusetts, typical annual premiums cost $138.

    However, it’s important to shop around and compare quotes so you can find an insurance plan that fits your budget and meets your needs.

    man paying
    Image Credit: Raten-Kauf, Pixabay

    What does renters insurance cover in Massachusetts?

    Renters insurance provides coverage for the items you keep in your residence, such as furniture, electronics, clothing, and more.

    It also covers any liability claims from accidents that occur at your home, as well as additional living expenses if your residence becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss.

    Most policies also include coverage for personal property damage caused by others, such as medical bills resulting from an injury to someone else while on your premises.

    Does renters insurance cover flooding in Massachusetts?

    No, most renters insurance policies do not include coverage for flood damage. If you live in an area where flooding is a potential risk, it’s important to purchase additional flood insurance to protect your home and belongings from water damage.

    What the Users Say

    Renters who have purchased a renters insurance policy in Massachusetts are typically appreciative of its affordability.

    As of 2023, renters insurance in Massachusetts is $22 cheaper than the national average. Additionally, many are happy with the coverage and customer service provided by the top companies.

    The most commonly praised aspects of renters insurance in Massachusetts are the variety of discounts available, such as a multi-policy discount if you bundle with another policy, plus additional discounts for military personnel or students.

    insurance contract showing male client where to write signature
    Image Credit: fizkes, Shutterstock

    Which Renters Insurance Provider Is Best for You?

    Whether you’re just starting out or have been renting for years, it’s important to find a renters insurance policy that best fits your needs.

    The 9 best renters insurance providers in Massachusetts all offer competitive rates and excellent customer service. Be sure to read reviews from current customers to get an idea of which provider is the right fit for you.

    Also, make sure to compare rates and discounts when shopping around for a policy—it may be worth considering more than one option before making your final decision.

    If you want an easy-to-manage policy from a provider that has a great reputation among Massachusetts renters, start your search with Lemonade Insurance.

    Thanks to its customer-friendly approach and lightning-fast claims process, it is one of the top 9 best renters insurance companies in Massachusetts and can provide you with the peace of mind that comes with knowing you’re protected.

    house divider


    Finding the best renters insurance in Massachusetts is made easy by our list of the 9 best providers for 2023. With competitive rates, plenty of discounts, and great customer service, you can be sure to get the coverage you need.

    Make sure to research each provider’s offerings before signing up for a policy so that you can find the best fit for your needs.

    Featured Image Credit: Travelpixs, Shutterstock

    Related posts

    OUR categories

    Project ideas

    Hand & power tools